Project 2: Elements of design

I had some doubts about choosing a subject for this project and finally, I selected the flowers and plants group. After having finished the project I have to tell that it was surprisingly fascinating the new world I've discovered.

So now let's explain the final compositions:


  • Single point dominating the composition.

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Tamron 90 mm Macro f/2,8
Exposure: 1/25   f/11
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.
I found this flower in a windy afternoon. The wind was a little obstacle to get the picture, but it didn't stop me so finally I got the shot I wanted when the wind calmed. I set the aperture to f/11 because I wanted the whole purple flower to be sharp, specially the blue and yellow parts, while I wanted its backgroung blurry to focus the attention on the flower.

Here the flower is dominating the composition because its color is contrasting with the dominant green in the scene and in my opinion, it makes the photograph so beautiful.


  • Two points

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 200 mm
Exposure: 1/125   f/4,8
ISO 200. No flash, tripod used.

I saw a couple of plants growing in the edge of the road. I looked at them and realized that although their root was placed in the same point, one of them was riper than the other because one was completely red when the other had a gradient between green to red.

If we compare the two points in the scene (the two plants here), we can see that the left one has more contrast that the other because the right plant has some green as the background. So the main point here would be the red plant.

I chose a large aperture because I wanted to focus the attention on the two plants while I separated them from the background but I'm afraid of not having solve this problem because the camera was too close from the points.

The vertical framing and the lines drawn by their stems (also vertical) simbolize the idea of growth, which is emphasized by their colours because it means that the riper plant (the red one) has grown earlier.



  • Several point in a deliberate shape

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Tamron 90 mm Macro f/2,8
Exposure: 10 sec.   f/22
ISO 200. No flash, tripod used.

It has been by far the most difficult exercise in this project. I think that shooting to something you find in nature is easier than creating a situation that you like to get shot. And of course, you need more time (most times, depending on what you're shooting) to think the composition and to prepare it. 

What I most like about photography is when I've decided my subject and I start thinking about where to position the camera, think about if it's gonna be a low angle, high angle or eye level shot and so on. Here in this exercise the challenge was another one because first I placed the camera and chose the point of view and then started filling the frame. To be honest I didn't believe that I was able to get a great shot because I had no idea of how to begin. But when I placed the first point and then another one, and another one, my mind started viewing different shapes like triagles and curves that helped in the final composition.

  • A combination of vertical and horizontal lines
Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Tamron 90 mm Macro f/2,8
Exposure: 1/80   f/5,6
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.

I was photographing a flower near this leaves when I saw it and I liked its highly saturated green colour against the stone so it got my attention very soon. The tricky part of getting the picture was that it was in the border of the river so I had to think about how I was going to place myself to get this point of view. Finally I decided to take a bird's eye shot. If there is any problem in this picture is that the foreground leaves are a distraction, but I there was nothing to do with them.

The combination of vertical and horizontal lines help to lead the eye in the right direction and make to look throught the image.

  • Diagonals 
Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 70 mm
Exposure: 1/1250   f/4,5
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.

I took this shot when I was going back home after a walk. I heard some birds and looked up when I saw some branches iluminated by a warm summer light and I became a little nostalgic so I got the idea about the composition of the shot. I chose a branch to be my diagonal I placed creating  a triangle with the edges of the frame to give more power to the picture. 

Here the main diagonal works pretty well to draw the eye through the image.  But there are also a lot of more diagonals in the picture drawn by smaller branches and leaves. They intersect with other diagonals creating a sense of action because the lines make the picture confusing.


  • Curves
Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Tamron 90 mm f/2,8
Exposure: 1/100   f/11
ISO 200. No flash, tripod used.


This is a plant's close up. I took out my camera and the tripod to the balcony and started experimenting with the macro lens. It was rainning so I wasn't very interested in taking pictures with such a gloomy environment. After a while, the sun appeared and I took this picture because I liked how the stems' "hairs" were iluminated by the sun as well as I liked its light curved shape. 
The only problem is the distracting leave on the top left corner because it's not in focus altough I used a small aperture the macro lens is a little bit more difficult to work with. 

  • Distinct, even if irregular, shapes

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 300 mm
Exposure: 1/400   f/11
ISO 400. No flash, no tripod.

I was photographing the daisy when I realized that it was a small insect in it, so I used the telephoto lens. Here we can see two circles: the outer circle is implied  by the petals and the inner one is real (yellow). 

As when using circles in a composition, they attract the whole attention, so I tried to place it in the middle to balance the composition.

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 48 mm
Exposure: 2 sec.  f/16
ISO 200. No flash, tripod used.


Here I used the shape of a rose in the composition. The shape creates another element in the picture for the viewer eye to look through and helps to fill the frame.

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Tamron 90 mm Macro f/2,8
Exposure: 1/60   f/16
ISO 200. No flash, tripod used.
This flower's irregular shape captured my attention as well as its saturated color. I tried to focus the whole plant while blurring the background so the shape of the flower gets sharper and draws an inverted triangle.

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Tamron 90 mm Macro f/2,8
Exposure: 1/125   f/11   EV-1
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.

I found this plant containing four flowers when I went for a walk. It was very windy that afternoon so the flowers didn't stop moving. I needed a quick shutter speed to freeze their movement as the same time I needed the flowers to be in focus. I also was afraid of the exposure because the flowers are nearly white and I didn't want to overexpose them, so I set the exposure compensation to   -1. 

Here the flowers draw a trapezoid and the hanging pistils are lines suggesting movement because of their direction: the upper flowers' pistils make a curve towards the right bottom flower.

  • At least two kinds of implied triagles 
Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Tamron 90 mm Macro f/2,8
Exposure: 1/500   f/5,6   EV -1
ISO 200. No flash, no used.
I composed the image to get one flower higher than the other two, while these were at the same heigth, so the implied traingle with the appex at the top is quite obvious here.

It's another triangle in this shot just in the top. But this one is a real triangle because it's the shape of the green leaf.

If we take another look to the image, an oval can be seen also. We can see the top flower inside the oval, so it attacts the viewer's eye to it.

I've used a large aperture to separate the flowers from the background and lead the eye to them, because the contrast between the white cover and the pink flowers has a lot of power in the picture.  

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Tamron 90 mm Macro f/2,8
Exposure: 1/400   f/11
ISO 200. No flash, tripod used.

In this picture the implied triangle is also drawn by the three flowers but I think the appex is inverted (the centre of the bottom red flower), so it would be a triangle built in perspective.  

Although the dominant point is the pink flower because it is larger and the color is different from the others. Other reasons would be that it's placed following the rule of thirds and it's shape can be seen better.

I used this aperture because I wanted sharpness for the three flowers but I also wanted to separate the background and to blur it.

  • Rhythm
Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 70 mm
Exposure: 1/30   f/16
ISO 200. No flash, tripod used.

I don't understand very well the difference between rhythm and pattern. Well, I know in theory that rhythm is related to movement while pattern is static but in practice I don't see much difference sometimes. 

I took this picture, which I think is an example os rhythm because I think the eye moves around the picture getting a sense of depth. To get this sense of depth I used a small aperture, such as f/16, which gave me a shutter speed of 1/30. This was a little bit dangerous speed because it was slow in my opinion, and that's why  some flowers in the picture are blurry. 

Now that I'm lookin at the picture, I'm asking myself why I didn't set a higher ISO to get a faster shutter speed.



  • Pattern
Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 135 mm
Exposure: 1/60   f/11   EV -1
ISO 200. No flash, no used.
This is my example of pattern. I've chosen a repetition of different leaves which gives me a static sense. I chose a f/11 aperture to get everything in focus and I thought it was when I checked in the camera viewer but when I reached home and loaded the picture in my laptop I saw the dark green leave in the upper right side wasn't sharp enough. 


Exercise: Rhythm and Pattern

To be honest, I've to tell that I haven't understood the difference between rhythm and pattern yet. I know that in rhythm the eye follow a direction and pattern is a more static concept but I find them very similar.

I've chosen this picture for rhythm because I see a dynamic repetition in the opened windows and they create diagonal lines as the eye crosses the image from side to side.

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 190 mm
Exposure: 1/160   f/8
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.













For "pattern" I've selected the following photograph. It's a detail from the Vatican ceiling. I cropped it to leave outside the frame the ceiling edges, so the repetitive tiles fill the frame. 

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 18 mm
Exposure: 1/125   f/5
ISO 400. No flash, no tripod.

Exercise: Real and implied triangles

  1. Triangular subject. I found this fountain in the Peterhof Gardens. It reminds me to the Christams tree because of its triangular shape which is more evident because I used a slow shutter speed to show the water movement.

    Camera body: Nikon d90
    Lens: Nikkor 18-55 f/3,5-5,6
    Focal length: 18 mm
    Exposure: 1/60   f/22
    ISO 640. No flash, no tripod.

  2. Triangle by perspective, converging towards the top of the frame. I've used an old style narrow street as my subject in this picture and I've placed myself in the middle of the street to converge the lines as they go away and draw a triangular shape.

    Camera body: Nikon d90
    Lens: Nikkor 18-55 f/3,5-5,6
    Focal length: 24 mm
    Exposure: 1/15   f/8
    ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.

  3. Inverted triangle by perspective, converging towards the bottom of the frame. I've choosen this picture taken in the Chicen Itza's surroundings. The picture cold be included also in the category described above (triangle created by perspective converging towards the top) if we pay attention to the piles and the floor, but in this case the saturated sky contrasts with the grey stone pile and the shape of the triangle is very marked as we can see. This effect would be clearer if the trees on the right wouldn't there. 
Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 18 mm
Exposure: 1/4000   f/3,5
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.

1- Still-life arrangement to produce a triangle with the apex at the   top.



Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 30 mm
Exposure: 1/8   f/4,2
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.



The triangle is drawn by the black rounded parasol and black the light meter to the blue glasscase which forms the appex of the triangle; so the appex is at the top.

 2- Still-life arrangement with the apex at the bottom.

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 40 mm
Exposure: 1/8   f/5,3
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.


In the picture above the appex of the implied triangle is at the bottom, which is created by the two orange paper roses. They're so close that they form the appex. Their stems draw two of the triangle's sides, while the other sides is drawn by the imaginary line from the end of one stem to the another.

3-Three people.


Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4,0-5,6
Focal length: 130 mm
Exposure: 1/60   f/4,2
ISO 800. No flash, no tripod.


In the picture above the three people who are riding horses draw an inverted triangle.

Exercise: Implied lines

In the first part of the exercise we have two images: one with a bull and a matador and the other with two horses and a man.

  • In the bull's picture I see a curved lines just next to the matador's feet as the same time as I see another curved line from the bull's left back foot to the end of the cape.
  • In the horses' image the implied lines are straight. One goes from the man's head to the horse's snout and the othe from the man's eyes to the horse's feet.


Implied lines are not physical lines you can see. They are lines created by eye suggestion. Let's see some examples:

In the first picture, the implied lines work mainly to stablish a  distance relationship between the guards. The implied lines can be drawn from gun to gun as well as from hat to hat as shown in the picture below. 

In my opinion there are also a couple of implied lines more which go from foot to foot. In this case this line is related to the action of the scene because they suggest movement.

 
Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 50 mm
Exposure: 1/160  f/11
ISO 800. No flash, no tripod.

This is a detail of the Sain Basil's Cathedral in Moscow. Here the implied line draws a diagonal from one cross to another one, giving perspective and depth to the image. 


If we take a closer look, we also detect two more implied lines to the lower cross, creating a implied triangle in this case. These implied lines help to determine the distance and the importance between the points (in this case the domes).

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 70 mm
Exposure: 1/100  f/11
iSO 200. No flash, no tripod.



In the third picture, the implied lines are created by the row of buildings. They draw a diagonal line in perspective, giving depth to the scene. We also have a horizontal line drawn by the grass in the lower third which frames the action just above. And we have another diagonal line separating the grass form the building and creating the horizon. 

The vertical lines are created by the edges of the building and they help us to suggest the power of height in the picture. There are few peolpe included in the picture so they help us to be aware of the image's dimensions. 

We can draw implied lines between the people in the scene also. This lines help suggest us the distance between them, creating perspective and depth.  

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 70 mm
Exposure: 1/80  f/16
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.



The fourth picture was taken in the Kremlin, Moscow. Here the crosses draw a parallel line as the same time as the middle crosses also draw another one connecting them and givin a "s" like shape. 

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 55 mm
Exposure: 1/160  f/11
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.






Exercise: Curves

Curves are similar to diagonals because they cause a sense of movement and direction. Curves are very useful to direct the eye towards the subject in the picture.

Like in the first picture, we want to attract the interest on the red car because it gives the action to the image. So we use the curved road to direct the interest towards the main subject giving some pespective and depth to the picture at the same time.

 

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 70 mm
Exposure: 1/250  f/11
ISO 800. No flash, no tripod.


In the second picture we have different curved objects that draw the shape of the objects so we can identify them as the same time as they help our eye to look around.



Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 55 mm
Exposure: 1/125  f/11
ISO 200. No flash, tripod used.

This is the Helsinki's Cathedral dome. The curves and the contrast between the blue sky and the white building makes the picture very powerful, which is emphasized by the low angle camera position.











Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 55 mm
Exposure: 1/640  f/11
ISO 400. No flash, no tripod.

This beautiful organ is inside the Helsinki Cathedral. I tried to use the arch as a frame as well as a way to get some extra light because the scene was a little dark and I forgot my tripod at home. I used a high ISO because i wanted an small aperture to ensure the whole scene was in focus, but I didn't want the ISO too high to avoid the digital noise. 












Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 18 mm
Exposure: 1/4  f/11
ISO 500. No flash, no tripod.

Exercise: Diagonals

Diagonals are ascending or descending lines so they add a dinamic look to the pictures because they draw a line to lead the eye through the frame. When diagonals intersect with other lines they suggest depth to the picture. They also give a sense of perspective which is emphasized with converging diagonals with a wide angle lens as shown in the third picture below (focal length: 18 mm).

As diagonals are lines they can help dividing the frame, or also framing a point in the picture. As we can see in the fist picture diagonals lead the attention to the small ship in order to the big one. If the three diagonal rope weren't there the small ship would be nearly imperceptible but the diagonals help us to look around the picture and we can notice the small boat more easily.

Here are some examples of diagonals. I've included another picture drawing these diagonals.








Camera body: Nikon d90 
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,4-5,6
Focal length: 36 mm
Exposure: 1/250  f/11
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.







Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,4-5,6
Focal length: 34 mm
Exposure: 1/250  f/11
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.






Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,4-5,6
Focal length: 18 mm
Exposure: 1/400  f/16
ISO 800. No flash, no tripod.









Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,4-5,6
Focal length: 24 mm
Exposure: 1/500  f/16
ISO 800. No flash, no tripod.

Exercise: Horizontal and Vertical Lines

I've chosen different subjects for this exercise such as urban landscape, nature, sculptures or sailing boats. There are plenty of images in our lives in which vertical and horizontal lines are included. So it isn't very difficult to find them; the hard work begins when you have to choose how to reflect them in the composition using different angles of view, different focal lengths... 

Here are some examples, starting with the horizontal lines:

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 35 mm
Exposure: 1/800 f/5,0
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.

This is a building detail. The HORIZONTAL lines are created by the window rows. The white windows contrasts with the red background and separate the image into different parts. It's been a tricky image because of the distortion caused by the low angle shot. 

The horizontal windows give a sensation of stability to the picture, like nothing happens in this place, as it were permanent.

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 32 mm
Exposure: 1/1600 f/11
ISO 640. No flash, no tripod.

There are also horizontal lines in landscapes as shown here. The trees in the back create an horizon between the lake and the sky. Here the horizon is placed in the lower third to cause a more dramatic sensation  with the sky. The horizon divides the picture in a dramatic part (the sky) and a calm and quiet part (the lake). There is also another horizontal line in the picture. This is an horizontal curve to be more specific and divides the sand and the water. This curve helps to lead the attention to the rocks and following toward the top you find the grey dramatic clouds.

I've used a small aperture to get a great depth of field and get in focus as much as possible in the picture, because I wanted to attract the attention to the whole image.


Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 18 mm
Exposure: 1/1000 f/11
ISO 800. No flash, no tripod.

It is an image of the Moscow Theatre with its beautiful gardens in the front. The roof of the theatre draws an horizontal line which works also as the horizon between the building and the sky. In the front there's a low fence drawing another horizontal lines. There're more horizontal lines created by the separation between the garden squares. 

In this picture there're also two vertical lines leading the attention to the three brown doors in the middle of the frame. These lines give the picture a sense of depth and help to lead our eyes towards the centre of the image while we look around till we reach the doors.


Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 34 mm
Exposure: 1/320 f/16
ISO 640. No flash, no tripod.

In this pictute the subject is the statue, so I've chosen its side view to give the picture a static appearance. I've also selected the horizontal framing to accentuate the calming stable impact.

I should have used a larger aperture to limit the depth of field and try to focus the statue and blur the background but I didn't have time to change the camera settings.

Verical lines are very helpful to give dinamism to the picture and help to lead the attention towards a concrete point we want to emphasize. Here are some examples:


Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 36 mm
Exposure: 1/80 f/11
ISO 200. No flash, no tripod.

Trees and in a more specific way, trunks are a good example of vertical lines because it's their nature; so they convey a growth feeling. In this case, I've decided to place a tree in the centre of the picture so I've made it to be cut in two halves and give the shot a symmetrical appearance (not totally but mainly). 

I've used a small aperture to get a high depth of field and to get the farest tree in focus.


Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 26 mm
Exposure: 1/200 f/10
ISO 640. No flash, no tripod.

It's a detail of the Sibelius Monument in Helsinki. It's a stainless steel pipe sculpture and Ive managed to place myself below it and shoot upwards. The tricky part of the shot was to calculate the exposure because the contrast was too high, so I had to decide if I wanted to expose for the pipes in the shadow, try to make an average shot or expose for the pipes hit by the sun. So I've made a bracketing: I made three pictures with a 2 stops overexposure and underexposure. Finally the most I liked was the underexposed one, but I've made some fill light, bright and contrast adjustments.

Here the vertical lines are combined with round shadows to make the picture more impressive and giving power and strength to the image.



Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 70-300 mm f/4-5,6
Focal length: 70 mm
Exposure: 1/4000 f/4
ISO 500. No flash, no tripod.


I've seen this sailing ship and got a little bit impressed by its  masts. It was the only ship with three masts in the whole quay and its heigth was considerable and I've used these vertical lines to suggest that idea. So I've used the vertical framing to accentuate this height.

Here I should have used a wider angle to get the shot but I only had the telephoto and 70 mm was the widest angle, so I was limited a little because the mast are cut at the top of the image. I think a 50 mm lens would have worked much better in this case.

Camera body: Nikon d90
Lens: Nikkor 18-55 mm f/3,5-5,6
Focal length: 22 mm
Exposure: 1/400 f/16
ISO 640. No flash, no tripod.

In the picture above I've used these cilindrical structures and the chains as vertical lines to suggest the idea of strength in the picture. If I've chosen a bigger apeture and have taken out of focus the background the picture would have worked better but I was so tired that I didn't pay much attention to it.

Conclusion: 

Horizontal and vertical lines are easy to find in real life, so they are easy to photography. We can use horizontal lines to suggest calm and stability or permanence. Or we can use vertical lines to accentuate the height, give strength and power to a building, a sculpture... Also lines are appropriate to divide the frame into halves, thirds... or to lead the attention towards our subject.